Just Intonation and whole number frequency ratio systems.

Just Intonation is a tuning system which operates on the assumption that musical harmonics only occur at frequencies which are at small integer ratios to the fundamental pitch. The ratios selected for Just Intonation seem to aim at producing "beatless" music; which to my mind is a futile, a folly. see Pitch, Pi..... Chapter One.

The diagram below shows where some of these ratios occur in the first octave. (i.e. 0 - 1200 cents)
The pattern shown begins with 3/2 at 702 cents, and ascends via the series 4/3, 5/3, 5/4, 6/5,...... .
The numbers 0 - 1200 in 100 cent increments are the positions used in 12tET as a reference. Remember that the graph represents cents. It is on a log scale, (like a fretboard, or slide rule), so that the midpoint in frequency
(pitch*1.5 = 702 cents) is at the 58.5% (7.02/1200) position across the graph.
The positions shown in blue are the result of the integer ratios using all integers up to and including 8 for the divisor.
The positions shown in white use the integers from 9 to 16 as the divisor.

Graph of integer ratios up to 15/8 and 31/16
You may notice some significant and interesting patterns in this graph:
1. As the integers increase, many "new" values will fall at ratios which were previously hit. Eg. 6/4 = 3/2 etc.
2. There is an absence of "hits" close to values and their multiples, which are frequently hit. Notice the gaps around 3/2 (702 cents), 5/3 (884 cents) ....... These are the ratios which are believed to be particularly significant in Just Intonation. If you are looking for a pitch as the Vth (i.e. around 700 cents) for your music; there is only one choice.
3. There are no hits near the ends of the graph, as to hit these locations requires large divisors.
4. The hits each side of 702 cents are "mirror images".
To compare graph above to first 44 steps of fourth and fifths using LucyTuning.

comparison of LucyTuning to low integer ratio tuning (Just Intonation)

Many advocates of Just Intonation claim that lower integer ratios produce more consonant intervals, than higher integer ratios. The exact size of intervals is determined by their position in a scale. Eg. from C to D (One Large interval (L) in LucyTuning), may be of different sizes in Just Intonation, dependent upon what note is considered to be the tonic of the scale in which it is used. This can result in what is know as in JI circles, "wandering tonics"., and creates retuning requirements during modulation and transposition. I consider JI to be a simplistic, paradoxical, naive, single dimensional and static mapping system for tuning, although many "die-hards", are currently attempting to resuscitate it.

Four fourths plus one third: should they equal two octaves?
 

Note Position Just 

Intonation

Pythagorean 

Tuning

Interval 

L & s to next

C I 4/3 4/3 2L+s
F IV 4/3 4/3 2L+s
Bb bVII 4/3 4/3 2L+s
Eb bX 4/3 4/3 2L+s
Ab bXIV 5/4 81/64 2L
C XVI Product is 

(256/81)*(5/4)=

Product is 

(256/81)*(81/64)=

__________
Total 

Ratio

2 Octaves 

4.0

Less than 2 Octaves

3.9506173

2 Octaves 

4.0

10L+4s 

4.0

Note Position Just 

Intonation

Pythagorean 

Tuning

Interval 

L & s 

Info. on Meantone tuning
Info on Pythagorean tuning
Info. on Equal temperaments

LucyTuning homepage 


If you are still convinced that Just Intonation could be useful for your musical endeavours; here are some links to more information on other microtuning and associated sites so that you can see, hear, and draw your own conclusions.
Bookmark here first; and come back soon!. 


Links out of LucyTuning to other websites about microtuning and other views on tuning.
Interesting ideas on timbre and tuning from Sethares (recommended)
American Festival of Microtonality
Southeast Just Intonation Center
FTP to Scala - a tuning program
RealTimeTuner
Bill Alves - JI information
Justonic commercial JI tuning program
- bye-bye!